VDI vs. VPN – How to Best Weather the Storm

Blog / Virtual Desktops / VDI vs. VPN – How to Best Weather the Storm


When thinking about VDI vs. VPN, there are many things to consider—especially with a winter storm taking place. We here in the Greater Philadelphia area are rounding up to about 6 inches of snow at 4 pm, and it’s still snowing steadily. Luckily, I’m well-equipped to work from home with my virtual desktop (VDI).  This morning, I discovered that my husband is not so well-equipped when I heard frustrated grumbling emanating from his office, as I was typing away. I called out and asked him, “What’s wrong?” His response: “Grrrrr! I can’t connect to the VPN.”

Ironically, what I’d just been working diligently on was writing an analysis of a new survey we just completed about “the state of the desktop” – and specifically about the mobility enablement that virtual desktops provide versus the challenges and disadvantages of using a virtual private network (VPN) for mobility enablement.

Our new survey (paper coming soon!) found that 65.5 percent of respondents are still using a VPN to access their network versus 18.5 percent that are using Desktop-as-a-Service (DaaS) or Virtual Desktop Infrastructure (VDI), who are able to access their entire desktop image on any device.

We get it – historically VPN was the solution of choice, so businesses continue using it. But, with VPN, you still only have your local machine, which means you have to download the files and save them locally in order to work on them. Plus, while VPN provides access to files on the corporate network, you still can’t access your work desktop applications locally over the VPN. With a virtualized desktop, secured and managed by your IT team and service provider, you are logging into the actual desktop you use every day at the office, and your documents are all right where they were when you were last working on them, already open and ready to resume.

Without even speaking to the myriad other advantages of DaaS, just from a mobility perspective, you are still lugging a heavy laptop home with you to log onto the network with a VPN. What you don’t get from VPN is the administrative advantages of DaaS, or the platform to run on any operating system or on mobile devices.

With VPN, you will also have to deal with bandwidth issues (just ask my husband.) While a VPN provides you with access to your companies’ network, the experience is dependent on the functionality of your machine and the traffic running through the VPN at the time. Especially if it is being leveraged during bad weather events to allow employees to work from home, when everyone in the organization is snowed in at home and using it at the same time, you will likely encounter issues.

Additionally, there are inherent security risks with VPN. Many executives and business end-users have a misconceived notion that the VPN is an encrypted tunnel between their device and the network.  In actuality, when allowing a device to VPN into your corporate network, you expose your network to problems on the home network. If you don’t have local virus protection or firewall, you are endangering the corporate network. Although your communication is encrypted over VPN, the risk is still there to pass along virus or malware, and the more open tunnels there are into your environment, the more paths are opened that now have access to it.

Do you really want to be the employee who passes a virus along to your company? Now here comes the difference between a VPN vs. VDI environment.

With a virtual desktop solution, the device you are using never actually touches the desktop – it is simply being accessed via a client or web-browser – so the security risk is mitigated. While many virtual desktop offerings feature built-in antivirus and malware protection for the desktop, those security elements are not necessary on the device. End users access their full desktops via a client or web browser via secure SSL.

A VDI workspace is a more efficient and secure way for companies to keep employees productive outside the four corporate walls. With DaaS or VDI, you can deliver a consistent, productive environment to end-users on any device – including Mac devices – from any location. You will mitigate user-productivity issues, regardless of device and enable users to use their own devices. Most importantly, you now know the key differences between a VDI vs. VPN, and you will never again have to exclaim “Grrrrr! I can’t connect to the VPN.”

Your essential IT ally for the enterprise hybrid workforce.

MSG_Arena_Primary_Logo-full-blue Nike_logo ford-img marriott-img chk-img apria-img
International accounting firm increases productivity by 30% during COVID with fully integrated Work Anywhere™ solutions.

Everything was flowing, everyone's connecting...Just seamless! And everything just worked. We haven't been down since we went remote."

– Chief Information Officer, Friedman, LLP

Dermatology Logo Partners
One of the nation’s largest and fastest-growing dermatology businesses estimates savings of $6.45 Million over 5 years

Evolve IP’s digital workspaces have allowed us to acquire more practices in a faster and more profitable way. That is resulting in bottom-line cost savings and top-line business benefits."

– Jeff Francis, Vice President of IT USDP

Ogletree Deakins Logo
International Law Firm Drives Communications Reliability Across 60+ Worldwide Locations and Saves Over $300,000 a Year

That’s the type of proposition I like to bring to a Board of Directors. When I can say, ‘we can get everything new, be completely redundant, it can meet all of our needs and oh, by the way, we are going to save over $300,000 a year.’ It makes it easy for me to sell!"

– Ken Schultz CIO of Ogletree Deakins

Simplify and future-proof your technology footprint with Evolve IP

Microsoft_logo partner_cisco_logo_120 VMware_by_Broadcom_Gray-Black_logo partner_citrix_logo_sized partner_zerto_logo_120 veeam-logo dubber-logo

It's nearly impossible to stay on top of every change in technology. Partner with Evolve IP and gain the combined experience of hundreds of technologists, all acting as an extension of your IT team. Helping you do more with less.

Featured By
 Frost and Sullivan Logo Gartner Logo Inc 5000 Logo Fox Business Logo
Certified By
Hitrust Logo AICPA Logo